Beethoven: Tragedy and Triumph

Overture, Coriolanus, op. 62 . . . . . . CA. 8’

Piano Concerto no. 3, op. 37 . . . . . . CA. 36’
with soloist Alon Goldstein

Intermission . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .CA. 15’

Symphony no. 3, “Eroica”, op. 55 . . CA. 52’


Program Notes:
Beethoven: Tragedy and Triumph

Overture, Coriolanus, op. 62

The works on today’s program come from Beethoven’s middle years, the period Maynard Solomon (Beethoven, 1977) calls the composer’s “heroic decade”, noting that between 1803 and 1812 he “…attained an awesome level of productivity…his works included an opera, an oratorio, a mass, six symphonies, four concertos, five string quartets, three trios, three string sonatas, and six piano sonatas, plus incidental music for a number of stage works, many Lieder, four sets of piano variations, and several symphonic overtures.”

Heinrich Joseph Collin (1772-1811), a Viennese poet and playwright, completed his tragedy Coriolan in 1802. It enjoyed some popularity for three years and then vanished from the stage. Beethoven’s overture to the drama appeared in 1807, although it is not impossible that he was thinking of Shakespeare’s Coriolanus as well. First performed at private concerts early in March 1807, it preceded an isolated revival of the play on April 24 of that year, but the combined effect of music and drama did not generate sufficient enthusiasm to rescue Collin’s play. In contrast, Beethoven’s overture, in his unmistakable stern C-minor idiom, has held a secure place in the symphonic repertoire ever since.

© Copyright Joel Lazar

Piano Concerto no. 3, op. 37

While Beethoven’s symphonies, piano sonatas and string quartets cover a nearly continuous span of more than thirty years, from the mid-1790s to 1826, the year before his death, his five published piano concerti were written between during a more restricted, earlier time-span, from 1788 and 1809, although an early work in this form (of which only the piano part survives) dates from 1784 and he abandoned work on a sixth concerto as late as 1815.

The chronology of the first three piano concerti is confused; the B-flat concerto published in 1801 as No. 2, Op. 19 precedes the C major concerto, Op. 15, published in 1800 as No. 1; sketches for the B-flat concerto go back as far as 1788 while sketches for the C-major concerto start in the mid-1790s. Although a few important sketches for the third, C-minor concerto can probably be dated from the mid-1790s, and for many years most scholars believed that it was complete by 1800, the latest research suggests that it was composed between May 1802 and March 1803, completed in time for performance in Vienna on April 5, 1803. The cadenza to the first movement, like those for the first movements of Op. 15 and Op. 19, dates from 1809.

Tonight’s concerto is probably contemporary with the Second Symphony, the Op. 30 violin sonatas, the Op. 31 piano sonatas, and the piano variations Op. 34 and Op. 35. Along with these works, it stands on the boundary between Beethoven’s early and middle styles. It is at times still clearly influenced by received late Classical form and procedure, but as in his other music of this transitional period we are confronted as well with a vastly expanded time-scale, range of pitch, scheme of dynamic contrast and range of textures, not only in comparison to similar compositions of Haydn and Mozart but also vis-à-vis his own earlier works.

The C-minor concerto occupies an interesting place in the history of the genre; some aspects of its first and last movements were influenced by the great minor-key piano concerti of Mozart, K. 466 (for which Beethoven also wrote cadenzas in 1809) and K. 491. Beethoven must have been thinking of K. 491 when he wrote the surprising, initially quiet coda which follows the first movement of this afternoon’s concerto.  In turn the finale of Brahms’ D-minor concerto, Op. 15 (completed in 1859) pays homage to that of the Beethoven C-minor; perhaps the youthful Brahms, writing the grandest and most symphonic piano concerto since Beethoven’s “Emperor” (1809) turned here to Beethoven for validation as he was again to do in his First Symphony. Some scholars have suggested that the slow movement of our concerto is to some extent modelled on that of Haydn’s Symphony No. 99 (1793); both are in slow triple rhythm, with a hymnic main theme, are in an unexpected major key a third removed from that of the first movement, and each ends with a surprising loud chord.

Cadenzas to the outside movements and Eingänge (florid transitional lead-ins) to the finale are by Beethoven.

© Copyright Joel Lazar

Symphony no. 3, “Eroica”, op. 55

“Eighteen hundred and three was the main year of composition of the Eroica Symphony, the centerpiece of the great stylistic transition that emerged out of Beethoven’s personal and artistic crisis of 1802…In the Third Symphony, Beethoven’s ‘new path’ ascended to a lofty summit with a commanding position in the history of the symphonic genre.” (William Kinderman, Beethoven, 1995).

“The first of Beethoven’s immense expansions of classical form is the Eroica Symphony, finished in 1804…The symphony, much longer than any work in that form that preceded it, provoked some displeasure at its first public performance. The critics complained of its inordinate length, and protested against the lack of unity in this most unified of works…The public, indeed seems to have been ill-natured at the first performance and the work immediately divided its hearers into two furiously opposed factions.” (Charles Rosen, The Classical Style, 1997).

“In the winter of 1803-4 Beethoven plunged into full-time work on the symphony. It now grew to a length that dwarfed any previous symphony by him anyone else…The work expanded the time space of the symphony as never before, demanding an unprecedented degree of patience and concentration from concert audiences. But what marks the Eroica as pathbreaking is not only its epic length. At least equally important is the unity of musical ideas…” (Lewis Lockwood, Beethoven: The Music and the Life, 2003).

“With Beethoven’s… Eroica Symphony, we know we have crossed irrevocably a major boundary in Beethoven’s development and in music history as well…Beethoven took music beyond what we may describe as the pleasure principle of Viennese classicism; he permitted aggressive and disintegrative forces to enter musical form: he placed the tragic experience at the core of his heroic style. He now introduced elements into instrumental music that had previously been neglected or unwelcome. A unique characteristic of the Eroica Symphony—and of its heroic successors—is the incorporation into musical form of death, destructiveness, anxiety, and aggression, as terrors to be transcended within the work of art itself. And it will be this intrusion of hostile energy, raising the possibility of loss, that will also make affirmations worthwhile.” (Maynard Solomon, Beethoven, 1977).

© Copyright Joel Lazar

Our Musicians

Violin I

Yakov Shapiro, Concertmaster
Sharon Bartley Asst. Concertmaster
Teresa Gordon
Akiko Gomez
Anna Hallett Gutierrez
Sharon Jollie
Jennifer Klein 
Yukimi Kurata
Kathleen Robinson
Mary Thulson
Anna Weiksner 
Alice Yang

Violin II

Steven Schwadron, Principal
Rachel Jongerius, Asst. Principal
Arthur Bennett
Vanessa Johnson
Naomi Malka
Arthur Sloan
Natasha Tynes
Kirsten Williams
Adela Wynn

Viola

Ayocuan Pacheco, Principal
David Jollie, Asst. Principal
Henry DeMarais
Paige Gilmore
Christen Hooks
Megan Weiner Mansfield
Elizabeth Roy
Charlotte Schoenbaum Sanford
Rachel Schmeltz
Zachary Vip
Jaap Van Wesel

Cello

David Zelinsky, Principal
Phillip Hummel, Asst. Principal
Sheryl Friedlander
Sandy Kiefer
Martin Mangold
Miriam Schoenbaum
Samuel Soltoff
Alex Steil
Erica Young

Bass

Mark Stephensen, Principal
Franklyn Bess
Erik Cohen
Nathan Coughlin
Raymond Irving
David Lowe
Karen McCool

Flute & Piccolo

Eric Abalahin
Colleen Darkow

Oboe

Susan Herlick
Andrea Schewe

Clarinet

Christopher Hite
Steven Lawson

Bassoon

Bobbi-Jo Holtz
Don Loomis

Horn

Jim McIntyre
Jamin Morden
Mark Phillips

Trumpet

Gerald Hodgkins
Charlie Peterson

Timpani

Ronald Carlson

Stage Manager

Sean Bartley

Personnel Manager

Steve Lawson

Librarians

Sharon Jollie
David Jollie

Join the Symphony of the Potomac

Interested in becoming a member of the orchestra?
We are always open to new members of all ages. We also hold auditions in-person and virtually on a rolling basis throughout the year!

The SOTP takes musicians of all stripes, but is best suited for musicians who aren’t afraid of taking on difficult music.

Joel Lazar, Music Director

Joel Lazar has been acclaimed by the Washington Post as "…one of Washington's premier conductors of both old and new music…." He has conducted the Theater Chamber Players in engagements at the Kennedy Center, the Library of Congress, and on tour from 1986 to 2003. He has appeared as guest conductor with many orchestras and contemporary music ensembles in the Washington area, including a 20-year tenure as Music Director of the JCC Symphony Orchestra from 1988 until 2008. He has been Music Director of the Symphony of the Potomac since it was founded in 2008.

During the 1990s, he was Music Director of Alexandria-based Opera Americana, and was Principal Conductor for the In Series' opera productions from 1991 until 2011. He was a cover conductor for the National Symphony Orchestra from 1997 to 2001, sharing the stage with Music Director Leonard Slatkin in critically praised and enthusiastically received performances of Ives' Fourth Symphony in April 2001. Joel Lazar is also Music Director of the Washington Sinfonietta, with which he has been affiliated since 2007.

Music Director of the Tulsa Philharmonic from 1980 to 1983, Joel Lazar has also appeared with the orchestras of San Antonio, Louisville, Pasadena, Oklahoma City, Richmond, Harrisburg, Wheeling and Johnstown, with Sarah Caldwell's Opera Company of Boston, and was Music Director of the Richmond Philharmonic from 1990 to 1992. During a period of European residence he conducted the BBC Philharmonic, the Danish National Orchestra, the Tivoli Orchestra and the Scottish Baroque Ensemble in concerts, broadcasts and recordings. His performances and feature interviews have been broadcast by the BBC, Danmarks Radio, Bayerischer Rundfunk, WCLV-FM (Cleveland, Ohio) and National Public Radio.

Upcoming Concerts

Bookended by two all-Beethoven programs, our season travels through the color and drama of the Russian tradition and the warmth, vitality, and joy of Dvořák. Purchase once and enjoy four afternoons of live orchestral music with the Symphony of the Potomac.

All concerts begin at 3:00 p.m. at the Montgomery College Cultural Arts Center in Silver Spring, Maryland.

Russian Rhapsody

January 31, 2027 at 3:00 p.m.

• Borodin: Overture to Prince Igor
• Shostakovich: Piano Concerto no. 2
     soloist Rachel Franklin
• Tchaikovsky: Symphony no. 5

Dvorak from the Old World

April 11, 2027 at 3:00 p.m.

• Dvořák: Overture, Carnival
• Dvořák: Violin Concerto
with soloist Ava Pakiam
• Dvořák: Symphony no. 8

Beethoven: Classical and Romantic

May 23, 2027 at 3:00 p.m.

• Beethoven: Symphony no. 2
• Beethoven: Symphony no. 4